Piles Coppice – the WWT Response

50 Years logo trans and white

Warwickshire Wildlife Trust has responded to our article on Monday “Conservationists Fall out over Piles Coppice”.

Nick Feledziak, Dunsmore Woodlands and Brandon Marsh Officer, writes

“To give you a bit of background, the consultation surrounding this management plan is an early stage consultation that was sent out to local neighbours, stakeholders and wildlife/ environmental conservation groups in June and is not a public consultation at this stage. I understand the plans have been shared more widely by certain stakeholders who have voiced their opinion out of context and without any explanation of the Trust’s rationale or the scale of the work intended.”

In an attached press release the Trust states

“Warwickshire Wildlife Trust advocates for actively managing wildlife habitats for biodiversity and sustainable woodland management can help secure the long term future of woodlands.  As demonstrated by science, trees of different ages and varied structures due to cyclical felling, thinning and coppicing will attract a bigger range of wildlife, and will also be more resilient to pests, diseases and climate change. Therefore, one of the biggest threats to our woodlands is the decision not to manage them.

“Parts of the woodlands and Brandon Reach and Piles Coppice haven’t seen management since around the 1950s, and particularly in Piles Coppice the woodland has almost fully closed over and consists mainly of deteriorating and even-aged small leaved lime coppice stools and closed-canopy oak high forest. Whilst this type of woodland benefits many common species adapted for such conditions, some of the threatened and rare species that require a varied structure and differing levels of light and micro-climates are in danger of being squeezed out. The woodland is also lacking enough canopy gaps and light to encourage the next generation of trees to come through, which would replace the older trees once they reach the end of their natural life expectancy. This is particularly concerning in a woodland made up of mainly similar aged trees, and threatens the long-term stability of the wood.

“Following two years of monitoring wildlife and engaging with local groups and individuals, Warwickshire Wildlife Trust are currently developing plans to establish how to reintroduce sensitive management in a woodland that has not been managed for some time. The Trust is currently liaising with local stakeholders, including neighbours, environmental groups and wildlife conservation experts in order to best balance the protection many individual important features within the woodlands. Following this consultation and the implementation of any adaptations, the plans will then need to be approved by the Forestry Commission who will assess the plans against the UK Forestry Standards (UKFS) which is the UK government’s approach to sustainable woodland management.  To gain approval, the plans will have to address the protection of biodiversity, the woodland’s protection from climate change and consider the historic environment, the current landscape, and the people who currently use the woodland. The plans will also need to protect the important woodland soils and natural water courses.

“Within Brandon Reach, the focus will also be on thinning out ash trees in favour of alternative species. The disease ash die-back has been devastating ash trees throughout the country as it sweeps its way north, and has now reached the Coventry area. As the ash trees die they become dangerous to people and property, and where they form the majority of a woodland, as within parts of Brandon Reach, the ecology of the woodland can also be threatened. So, Warwickshire Wildlife Trust is planning ahead by removing potentially hazardous trees and thinning woodland blocks in favour of alternative native species. This should add some resilience to the woodland and provide long-term protection for wildlife and people.

“The management work will be in part achieved by contractors and whilst woodland management can appear destructive, cause temporary inconvenience, and hamper accessibility – the woodland soon recovers.  During these works the contractors will avoid using the path network wherever possible and any areas that are disturbed will be repaired before works are completed.

“Locals can get involved in their local woodlands by volunteering with the Trust, and the charity aims to provide positive opportunity and continued access for local people through our woodland management; making them healthy and vibrant places for both people and wildlife.”


Nick Feledziak adds “We haven’t fallen out with the Coventry Tree Warden Network. We have engaged positively with a range of stakeholders including some who a very emotive view of the wood. We have met the Coventry Tree Wardens on several occasions to discuss our plans and hear their concerns.

“We refute the claim that the motivation is firewood and that unsuitable machinery is the intention, this appears to be the opinion of Ms. Wilson. We manage woodlands for the long term benefit of wildlife and people, not for commercial gain.”

We are happy to publish this added information.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s